Working Group on Science of Science

Introduction

As the largest public funder of biomedical research in the world, NIH is the driving force behind decades of advances that have expanded scientific knowledge and improved health. As stewards of public funds, NIH continues to seek new ways to engage the research community, including science of science, which applies rigorous and empirical analysis to study how science is done, to help us understand the impacts of NIH policies and programs. NIH has a long history of engaging with researchers to generate evidence to inform improvements to its programs, policies, and processes. This includes making a wide array of grants-related data and statistics publicly available through the NIH Research Portfolio Online Reporting Tools (RePORT) website and providing outside researchers access to NIH administrative data. NIH also supports research to strengthen NIH decision making through the NIGMS Science of Science Approach to Analyzing and Innovating the Biomedical Research Enterprise Program. Recently, the Office of Extramural Research and the Office of Evaluation, Performance, and Reporting launched a pilot NIH Science of Science Scholars Program that will pair science of science researchers with NIH staff to conduct in-depth analyses on NIH processes, programs and outcomes of NIH-supported research. In light of these efforts and other advancements in biomedical research, NIH is seeking continual improvement in generating evidence to inform its work and to drive more discoveries to improve health.

Charge of the Working Group

To maximize NIH’s use of evidence in decision-making, DPCPSI is seeking advice from experts to identify scientific areas with the greatest potential for improving upon NIH’s programs, policies, and operations. Specifically, the Council of Councils Working Group on Science of Science is charged with:

  1. Reviewing the efforts that NIH has undertaken to generate evidence about its programs, policies, and processes.
  2. Identifying significant gaps in knowledge where leveraging science of science and related research may better influence NIH decision-making.
  3. Providing recommendations on potential approaches that NIH could consider to enhance its use of the science of science and ensuing results.
  4. Providing recommendations for how NIH can engage the science of science research community and communicate results of science of science research.

Roster

Co-Chairs

Kevin C. Kent Lloyd, DVM, PhD 
Council of Councils Member
Distinguished Professor, Department of Surgery 
School of Medicine
Director, Mouse Biology Program
Associate Director, Comprehensive Cancer Center
University of California, Davis

Marina Volkov, PhD
Director
Office of Evaluation, Performance, and Reporting
Division of Program Coordination, Planning, and Strategic Initiatives 
Office of the Director 
National Institutes of Health

Executive Secretary

Ira Kuhn, PhD
Science Advisor to the Director
Office of Evaluation, Performance, and Reporting
Division of Program Coordination, Planning, and Strategic Initiatives 
Office of the Director 
National Institutes of Health

Members

Pierre Azoulay, PhD
International Programs Professor of Management
Professor, Technological Innovation, Entrepreneurship, and Strategic Management
Sloan School of Management
Massachusetts Institute of Technology

Maryann Feldman, PhD
Watts Professor of Public Policy and Management
Watts College of Public Service and Community Solutions
Professor
School of Public Affairs
Research Director
Global Center for Technology Transfer
Arizona State University

Monica Gandhi, MD, MPH
Council of Councils Member
Director, UCSF-Bay Area Center for AIDS Research 
Professor of Medicine and Associate Chief
Division of HIV, Infectious Diseases, and Global Medicine
University of California San Francisco

Daniel Goroff, PhD 
Vice President and Program Director
Alfred P. Sloan Foundation

Karen C. Johnston, MD, MSc 
Council of Councils Member
Harrison Distinguished Professor of Neurology, Department of Neurology 
Associate Vice President for Clinical & Translational Research 
Office of the Vice President for Research 
University of Virginia

Julia Lane, PhD
Professor Emerita
Wagner Graduate School of Public Service
Provostial Fellow for Innovation Analytics
New York University Wagner

Jennifer J. Manly, PhD
Council of Councils Member
Professor of Neuropsychology
Taub Institute for Research on Alzheimer’s Disease & the Aging Brain
Department of Neurology 
Columbia University Irving Medical Center

Brian Nosek, PhD
Co-Founder and Executive Director
Center for Open Science
Professor
University of Virginia

Mikko Packalen, PhD
Associate Professor 
Department of Economics 
University of Waterloo

Bhaven Sampat, PhD
Research Professor
School of Government and Policy
Carey Business School
Johns Hopkins University

Dashun Wang, PhD
Kellogg Chair of Technology
Professor of Management & Organizations
Professor of Industrial Engineering & Management Sciences
Director, Center for Science of Science and Innovation
Co-Director, Ryan Institute on Complexity
Director, Northwestern Innovation Institute
Northwestern University

Caleb Watney, MA
Co-Founder and Co-CEO
Institute for Progress

Bruce Weinberg, PhD
Eric Byron Fix-Monda Endowed Professor of Economics and Public Affairs
Ohio State University

This page last reviewed on