COUNCIL OF COUNCILS
Chimpanzees Research Use Panel
Background and Charge of the Panel
As explained in 78 Fed. Reg. 39741 (“the FRN”), among other things, the agency accepted the Council recommendation to establish a panel, which is independent of the existing NIH review processes (e.g., peer review of grants and technical evaluation of contracts and scientific review of NIH intramural research), to consider whether requests to the NIH to use chimpanzees in research are consistent with the IOM principles and criteria. A working group of the NIH Council of Councils, the Chimpanzee Research Use Panel (CRUP or “Panel”) was created and charged with considering requests to use chimpanzees in research. The CRUP will convene before the NIH makes decisions about funding or otherwise allowing research involving chimpanzees but after the NIH peer review, technical evaluation, or other applicable review processes are completed for grant applications, contract proposals, and intramural research protocols. Consistent with the IOM report, the NIH accepted the Council’s recommendation that certain observational or non-interventional research involving chimpanzees and certain research involving chimpanzee biomaterials will be exempt from the CRUP’s consideration.
Consideration by the CRUP and Council of Councils
CRUP members will convene before the NIH makes funding decisions or otherwise allows the research to proceed but after the NIH peer review, technical evaluation, or other applicable reviews are completed for grant applications, contract proposals, and intramural research protocols. In accordance with laws governing the federal advisory committee process, the CRUP will present its recommendations to the Council of Councils, which, in turn, will make recommendations to the appropriate NIH IC Director(s).
When Does the CRUP Meet?
The CRUP will meet three times per year, as needed, and after the NIH IC Advisory Councils or Boards convene and recommend grant applications for funding. Although the CRUP schedule is tied to extramural advisory bodies that advise the NIH on grants, the CRUP meeting schedule in the "Due Dates" section applies to contracts, intramural research, and third party research as well. Due to discussions of proprietary information that are expected to occur, CRUP meetings will not be open to the public.
When Does the Council of Councils Meet?
After the CRUP considers the requests to use chimpanzees in research, they will inform the NIH Council of Councils of their findings during its closed session discussion. The Council of Councils meets three times per year, according to the schedule in the "Due Dates" section. Recommendations from the Council of Councils will be transmitted to the appropriate NIH IC Director(s) to be taken into consideration when making funding decisions or otherwise determining whether the research should proceed.
This section contains general information about upcoming due dates as they relate to research involving chimpanzees. Meetings of the CRUP will occur up to three times per year if there are CRU Forms to consider.
|Cycle||Receipt*||Scientific Review*||Advisory Council Review*||Form Due**||CRUP Meeting***||Council of Councils Review****|
|Cycle II||May–Jun 2014||Sep–Oct 2014||Jan–Feb 2015||Mar 3, 2015||May 2015||Jun 19, 2015|
|Cycle III||Sep–Oct 2014||Jan–Feb 2015||May–Jun 2015||Jul 1, 2015||Aug 2015||Sep 1, 2015|
|Cycle IV||Jan–Feb 2015||May–Jun 2015||Sep–Oct 2015||Nov 2, 2015||Dec 2015||Jan 29, 2016|
|Cycle V||May–Jun 2015||Sep–Oct 2015||Jan–Feb 2016||Mar 1, 2016||Apr 2016||May 20, 2016|
|Cycle VI||Sep–Oct 2015||Jan–Feb 2016||May–Jun 2016||Jul 1, 2016||Aug 2016||Sep 9, 2016|
* applicable only to grant applications. Due dates for AIDS and AIDS-related applications are May 7 for Sep.-Oct. Advisory Council, Sept. 7 for Jan.-Feb. Advisory Council, and Jan. 7 for May-June Advisory Council. Due dates for contract proposals and intramural research protocols are specified by the contracting office and/or NIH IC.
** dates are approximate. The NIH will communicate the final due date at the time the agency asks the applicant or offeror to complete the Chimpanzee Research Use Form.
*** applicable to only research determined by the NIH to be subject to CRUP consideration.
**** future dates will be available at:
For questions regarding a specific grant application, please contact the NIH program officer associated with the application. For questions regarding a specific Request for Proposals, please contact the assigned NIH Contracting Officer. NIH intramural researchers, third parties, and others may direct questions to email@example.com.
Terry L. Jernigan, PhD (co-chair)
University of California, San Diego
La Jolla, CA
Keith A. Reimann, DVM (co-chair)
The Reverend Canon Kim Turner Baker, JD, MDiv
Washington National Cathedral
James G. Else, DVM, MPVM
Agustin Fuentes, PhD
University of Notre Dame
Notre Dame, IN
Amye L. Leong, MBA
Santa Barbara, CA
Sarah J. Ratcliffe, PhD
University of Pennsylvania
Richard R. Sharp, PhD
James H. Wendorf
National Center for Learning Disabilities
New York, NY
This page last reviewed on March 28, 2018